Home » Blog » VFD Knowledge » VFD vs. Soft Starter: Differences, Working Principles and Applications

VFD vs. Soft Starter: Differences, Working Principles and Applications

When starting a large AC motor, high starting current and sudden mechanical shock can cause problems for both the electrical system and connected equipment.

A Variable Frequency Drive (VFD) and a soft starter are two common solutions. Both help reduce the impact of motor starting, but they work in different ways.

The main difference is simple: a soft starter controls motor voltage during starting and stopping, while a VFD controls both voltage and frequency to regulate motor speed throughout operation.

If your motor only needs a smooth start and then runs at full speed, a soft starter may be enough. If you need to adjust motor speed during normal operation, a VFD is usually the better choice.

Let’s look at how they work, their key differences, and where each one is used.

A Variable Frequency Drive (VFD), also called an AC drive or variable speed drive, is an electronic device used to control the speed and torque of an AC motor.

It works by changing the frequency and voltage supplied to the motor.

For example, a standard AC motor designed for 50 Hz operation can run at different speeds when the VFD changes its output frequency. This makes it possible to adjust the speed of pumps, fans, conveyors, compressors, and other industrial equipment.

How Does a VFD Work?

A typical VFD has three main sections:

  1. Rectifier: Converts incoming AC power into DC power.
  2. DC Bus: Filters and stores the DC energy.
  3. Inverter: Converts DC power back into AC power at the required frequency and voltage.

The VFD controls the inverter switching to produce the required output for the motor.

For example, reducing the output frequency can reduce motor speed. Increasing the frequency can increase motor speed, provided the motor and driven equipment are designed for that operating range.

Motor speed is related to supply frequency and the number of motor poles.

Synchronous Speed Formula

Ns = 120 × f / P

Where:

  • Ns = Synchronous speed (RPM)
  • f = Supply frequency (Hz)
  • P = Number of motor poles
Synchronous Speed for a Four-Pole Motor
Frequency Synchronous Speed
20 Hz 600 RPM
30 Hz 900 RPM
40 Hz 1,200 RPM
50 Hz 1,500 RPM
60 Hz 1,800 RPM

The actual speed of an induction motor is slightly lower because of slip.

This is why a VFD is useful when a machine needs different operating speeds instead of running at full speed all the time.

2. What Is a Soft Starter?

A soft starter is an electronic motor starting device designed to reduce the electrical and mechanical impact of starting an AC motor.

When a motor starts directly across the line, it can draw a high inrush current. This sudden current can cause voltage drops, while the starting torque can create mechanical stress on belts, gears, couplings, and other components.

A soft starter gradually increases the voltage supplied to the motor during startup. This allows the motor to accelerate more smoothly.

Unlike a VFD, a standard soft starter does not provide continuous motor speed control. Once the motor reaches full speed, it normally runs at the supply frequency.

How Does a Soft Starter Work?

Most electronic soft starters use SCRs (Silicon Controlled Rectifiers), also known as thyristors, to control the voltage supplied to the motor.

The basic process is:

  1. The motor starts with a reduced voltage.
  2. The soft starter gradually increases the voltage.
  3. The motor accelerates smoothly toward full speed.
  4. Once the motor reaches the required operating condition, a bypass contactor may connect the motor directly to the power supply.

Some soft starters also provide a soft-stop function. This gradually reduces motor voltage to help avoid sudden stopping.

However, soft stopping is not the same as full speed control. A soft starter mainly manages the motor’s starting and stopping process.

Industrial soft starter for reducing AC motor starting current

Both devices help reduce motor starting stress, but their functions and applications are different.

Here is a quick comparison:

FeatureVFDSoft Starter
Main FunctionMotor speed and torque controlSmooth motor starting and stopping
Working PrincipleChanges voltage and frequencyControls motor voltage
Speed ControlYes, during operationNo continuous speed control
Starting CurrentCan provide controlled acceleration and limit currentReduces starting current compared with direct-on-line starting
Starting TorqueCan provide better control, depending on drive type and settingsLimited by reduced starting voltage
Stopping ControlControlled deceleration and stoppingSoft stop on supported models
Energy SavingPossible with variable-speed loadsUsually limited
System ComplexityHigherLower
Initial CostUsually higherUsually lower
Typical ApplicationsPumps, fans, conveyors, compressorsPumps, fans, conveyors and fixed-speed motors

3.1 Speed Control

This is the biggest difference between the two.

A VFD can adjust motor speed during normal operation. For example, a water pump can run faster when demand increases and slower when demand decreases.

A soft starter only controls the starting process. After startup, the motor normally runs at its rated supply frequency and speed.

If your equipment needs to run at different speeds, choose a VFD.

3.2 Starting Current

Both devices can reduce the high current associated with direct-on-line motor starting.

A soft starter limits the voltage during acceleration. However, the motor’s starting torque also decreases as voltage is reduced. If the load requires high starting torque, the motor may take longer to accelerate or fail to start.

A VFD controls output frequency and voltage together. It can provide more precise control of motor acceleration and current, depending on the drive’s control mode and settings.

For applications with a weak power supply or high starting torque requirements, a properly selected VFD may be a better solution.

3.3 Energy Consumption

A VFD can reduce energy consumption when the motor operates under variable-load conditions.

For example, a fan or pump does not always need to run at full speed. Reducing motor speed can reduce the power required by the equipment.

A soft starter does not normally reduce motor speed after startup. If the motor runs at full speed continuously, the energy-saving benefit is usually limited to the starting process.

Keep in mind that a VFD does not automatically save energy in every application. The actual savings depend on the load, operating hours, system design, and speed requirements.

3.4 Cost and Maintenance

A soft starter is generally simpler and less expensive than a VFD of comparable motor rating.

It is a practical choice when the motor only needs a smooth start and then operates at a fixed speed.

A VFD usually has a higher initial cost because it includes more power electronics and control functions. It also requires proper attention to installation, cooling, electrical noise, harmonics, and motor compatibility.

However, when variable-speed control is required, a VFD can offer better process control and potential energy savings.

The best choice depends on how the motor operates and what the equipment needs.

Common VFD Applications

These applications are suitable when motor speed needs to change during operation.

Water Pumps

A VFD adjusts pump speed according to water demand or system pressure. It can help maintain stable pressure and reduce unnecessary energy consumption.

Industrial Fans

A VFD controls airflow by changing fan speed. This is useful in ventilation systems, HVAC equipment, and industrial dust collection systems.

Conveyor Systems

A VFD allows operators to adjust conveyor speed according to production requirements. It can also provide controlled acceleration and deceleration.

Air Compressors

Some compressor systems use VFDs to adjust motor speed according to air demand. The suitability depends on compressor type and operating conditions.

CNC Machines and Production Equipment

VFDs are used where motor speed needs to be adjusted for different machining or production processes.

Common Soft Starter Applications

A soft starter is suitable for motors that normally operate at a fixed speed but need a smoother startup.

Fixed-Speed Water Pumps

A soft starter reduces sudden mechanical stress during motor startup. With a suitable soft-stop function, it can also help reduce pressure surges in some pumping systems.

Industrial Fans

Large fans can create significant starting loads. A soft starter helps the motor accelerate gradually and reduces mechanical shock to the connected equipment.

Belt Conveyors

A sudden start can place extra tension on conveyor belts and mechanical components. A soft starter provides a smoother acceleration process.

Crushers and Industrial Machinery

Some fixed-speed machines use soft starters to reduce starting stress. However, the required starting torque and load conditions must be checked before selection.

Fixed-Speed Compressors

Some compressor applications use soft starters to reduce starting current. The compressor’s unloading arrangement and starting torque requirements should be considered.

There is no single answer for every motor. The right choice depends on the operating requirements.

Use the following guidelines:

Your RequirementRecommended Solution
Motor runs at one fixed speedSoft Starter
Motor speed needs frequent adjustmentVFD
Need smooth motor accelerationBoth
Need controlled decelerationVFD or soft starter with suitable soft-stop function
Need pressure control in a pump systemVFD
Need to adjust airflow in a fan systemVFD
Need to reduce mechanical shock during startupSoft Starter
Need better control of motor torque and speedVFD
Need a lower-cost starting solution for fixed-speed operationSoft Starter

Example 1: A Factory Water Pump

Suppose a factory uses a water pump that always operates at full speed.

The main problem is the high starting current and sudden mechanical impact when the pump starts.

In this situation, a soft starter may be sufficient.

However, if the water demand changes throughout the day and the pump needs to adjust its speed to maintain pressure, a VFD is usually more suitable.

Example 2: An Industrial Ventilation Fan

If the fan always operates at a fixed speed, a soft starter can help reduce mechanical stress during startup.

But if the ventilation system needs different airflow levels depending on production conditions, a VFD provides better control.

These examples show why motor power alone is not enough to determine which device to use. The actual operating conditions matter.

Yes. A VFD can normally perform the soft-starting function of a soft starter.

It gradually increases motor frequency and voltage during acceleration, allowing the motor to start smoothly. It can also control motor speed after startup.

However, this does not mean a VFD is always the best replacement.

If a motor only runs at full speed, a soft starter is often more economical and simpler to install.

A VFD may be a better investment when the application needs variable speed, process control, or energy savings from reduced motor speed.

Before replacing a soft starter with a VFD, check:

  • Motor rated voltage, current, and power.
  • Required starting torque.
  • Load type and acceleration time.
  • Motor insulation and cable requirements.
  • Harmonic and electromagnetic compatibility.
  • Cooling and installation conditions.
  • Existing protection and bypass arrangements.

The VFD must be selected according to the motor and load, not just the motor’s rated power.

7. What Should You Consider When Selecting a VFD or Soft Starter?

Before purchasing either device, check the following information:

1. Motor Power and Rated Current

Confirm the motor’s rated power, voltage, frequency, and full-load current from its nameplate.

2. Load Type

Different loads have different starting torque requirements.

For example, a centrifugal pump and a loaded conveyor may require different starting conditions.

3. Starting Frequency

How many times does the motor start per hour?

Frequent starting can increase thermal stress. Check the device manufacturer’s permitted starting frequency and cooling requirements.

4. Operating Speed

If the motor needs to run at different speeds, a VFD is generally the right choice.

If it only needs to reach full speed smoothly, a soft starter may be sufficient.

5. Power Supply Conditions

Check the incoming voltage, available supply capacity, and acceptable voltage drop during startup.

For installations with unstable supply voltage, the overall power system should also be evaluated. A motor controller does not replace the need for proper voltage regulation and electrical protection.

Choosing the right motor control equipment is important for stable operation, equipment protection, and production efficiency.

ZHENGXI provides industrial electrical equipment and customized solutions for different power and application requirements.

When selecting a VFD or soft starter, our team can help review motor ratings, load characteristics, operating conditions, and control requirements.

Whether your project needs variable-speed motor control or a smooth fixed-speed startup, choosing the correct solution starts with understanding the actual application.

Contact ZHENGXI to discuss your motor control requirements and find a suitable solution for your project.

What is the main difference between a VFD and a soft starter?

A VFD controls motor speed by changing output frequency and voltage. A soft starter controls motor voltage during startup and, if supported, stopping. It does not provide continuous speed control.

Which is better, a VFD or a soft starter?

Neither is better for every application. A VFD is suitable when variable-speed control is required. A soft starter is usually more economical when the motor only needs a smooth start and operates at a fixed speed.

Can a soft starter control motor speed?

No. A standard soft starter cannot continuously adjust motor speed. It gradually increases voltage during startup, after which the motor normally runs at full speed.

Does a VFD reduce motor starting current?

Yes. A VFD can control motor acceleration and limit starting current by adjusting output frequency and voltage. The actual current depends on the motor, load, control mode, and drive settings.

Can I use a VFD instead of a soft starter?

Yes. A VFD can normally provide soft starting and additional speed control. However, it usually costs more and may be unnecessary for applications that only require fixed-speed operation.

Which is better for a water pump, a VFD or a soft starter?

It depends on the pump system. A soft starter is suitable when the pump runs at a fixed speed and only needs smoother starting. A VFD is more suitable when pump speed needs to change according to water demand or pressure.

The choice between a VFD and a soft starter mainly depends on whether your motor needs speed control after startup.

A soft starter is a practical and cost-effective option for fixed-speed motors that need smoother acceleration. A VFD is more suitable for applications that require variable speed, better process control, or potential energy savings.

Before making a decision, consider motor power, load type, starting torque, operating speed, and actual working conditions. This will help you choose the right motor control solution for your equipment.

en_USEN
Scroll to Top